Showing posts with label gifted. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gifted. Show all posts

Friday, October 03, 2014

Ungifted by Gordon Korman




Ungifted, Gordon Korman. New York: Balzer + Bray/ HarperCollins Publishers, 2012. e-book, 172 pps.


     Some will recognize Gordon Korman as a prolific author of children's books. Ungifted is a cute book about a middle school boy named Donovan Curtis. Donovan whacked a school statue with a tree branch and there were consequences to his actions. The superintendent of schools was the one who caught him. Much to Donovan's surprise and the surprise of his entire family, he is sent to the gifted school.

     The gifted kids in his new classroom are portrayed as if they had Asperger's along with their superior I.Q.s. One is stuck on plaids, another does social stuff even less well than the others, and all of them are bad at sports. Donovan is a welcome addition to the class in spite of not really belonging there. 

sapphoq reviews says: The gifted kids I have known-- the ones who aren't Aspies anyway-- are prolific at social skills and at sports in addition to excelling at schoolwork. In spite of this small misgiving, I enjoyed Ungifted and I think middle school kids would also. Highly recommended.

Sunday, March 30, 2014

Asylum by Madeleine Roux




Asylum, Madeleine Roux. New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 2013. e-book, 216 pps.

Some teens labeled as gifted descent upon a college in New Hampshire for a summer program. They stay in a dorm building which used to be an asylum. Three of them become pals. Daniel is described in the book as being anxious and was given the label of "mild dissociative disorder." Jordan is a gay teen who is supposed to be somewhere else. Abby is an artist. They explore the warden's office on the first floor of the building and find other hidden stuff there.

sapphoq reviews says: I was dismayed by the label of "mild dissociative disorder." It seemed not to fit the story as it was told. I think it might have been better to use the words "fugue states" and to explain to the [probably mostly teen] readers what that is.

Asylum started off slowly. I didn't really get interested until the trio began their extended exploration of the secret rooms. Until that point, I was forcing myself to stick with the book. The ending was somewhat predictable. I would have liked also for the characters of Daniel's roommate and the history professor to be fleshed out a bit more. 

The old photos were pretty cool but easily located on the internet. 

A disappointing read, even for teens. Skip this.